A High Number of Americans Think Insurance Fraud Is Not a Crime

June 7, 2023 / 3 min read

JERSEY CITY, N.J. – June 7, 2023 – A significant number of Americans aged 45 and younger show a high level of tolerance for insurance fraud – even feeling envious of those who commit it – according to a new survey of insurance consumers by Verisk (Nasdaq: VRSK) and the Coalition Against Insurance Fraud.

The study analyzes how American consumers view insurance fraud and insurance crime and delves into the psychology of insurance fraud to understand the motivations and justification for the crime derived from in-depth interviews with those convicted of insurance fraud.

“This study should sound the alarm for insurers, consumer activists, regulators, and legislators on the state of fraud in America. While it’s marginally reassuring that 84% of Americans in the survey consider insurance fraud a crime, the 16% that do not consider it a crime potentially represent more than 53 million Americans,” said Matthew Smith, executive director of the Coalition Against Insurance Fraud. “There is a need for consumer education on the harm insurance fraud crimes have on our economy and on every American citizen and family.”

The study found that 87-96% of older respondents consider insurance fraud a crime, while only 75% of those under age 45 consider it a crime, with the percentage skewing downward by age to only 64% for the youngest group.

Other findings include:

More than 36% of all Americans believe it’s acceptable to submit an inflated auto damage claim
Over 30% of 25-34-year-olds “definitely would” submit a fraudulent property damage claim
27% of those 18-24 would commit workers’ compensation fraud, compared to less than 10% of those 45 and older
Over a quarter of those 18-34 are “motivated” to commit insurance fraud compared to less than 7% of those over 45

“The results prove the continued need for insurers to be hypervigilant about the impact of fraud on their book of business,” said Maroun Mourad, president of Verisk Claims Solutions. “The fact that younger generations are more tolerant and motivated to commit claims fraud indicates that this problem is not going away and is likely to persist in the future. Carriers would be wise to set up a strong perimeter defense to ensure they are adequately and accurately detecting potential fraud throughout the policy life cycle.”

The study, conducted by Dynata, collected more than 1,500 responses from a group of insurance-purchasing consumers matching the demographic standards identified in the 2020 U.S. Census. Learn more about the results of the study at a webinar on July 18.

About Verisk
Verisk (Nasdaq: VRSK) provides data-driven analytic insights and solutions for the insurance industry. Through advanced data analytics, software, scientific research and deep industry knowledge, Verisk empowers customers to strengthen operating efficiency, improve underwriting and claims outcomes, combat fraud and make informed decisions about global issues, including climate change and extreme events, as well as political and ESG topics. With offices in more than 20 countries, Verisk consistently earns certification by Great Place to Work and fosters an inclusive culture where all team members feel they belong. For more, visit Verisk.com and the Verisk Newsroom.

About the Coalition Against Insurance Fraud
Insurance fraud is the crime we all pay for, costing consumers more than $308.6B each year. Formed in 1993, the Coalition is the nation’s only alliance uniting all groups against insurance fraud. 280+ member organizations comprise the Coalition. Consumers, insurers, government agencies, legislators, prosecutors, and other committed partners come together under the Coalition banner. We fight all forms of insurance scams regardless of who commits the fraud. The power of our diversity and unity in protecting consumers earns the Coalition unparalleled credibility. The Coalition leads the fight against insurance fraud in our nation and with our global partners. The Coalition is governed by our Board of Directors and Executive Committee in accordance with our By-Laws.

A Surprisingly High Number of Americans Think Insurance Fraud Is Not a Crime, New Survey Shows